Thursday, June 29, 2017

Nothing About the White House’s Syria Announcement Was Normal

Nothing About the White House’s Syria Announcement Was Normal

By Heather Hurlburt

What? Photo: Cheriss May/NurPhoto via Getty Images

On Monday night, the White House warned that Syria’s Bashar al-Assad is preparing another chemical-weapons attack, and that if he follows through with it there will be “a heavy price.” The universal response was surprise. Because nothing can be assumed in analyzing the national-security actions of this administration — including competence or traditionally responsible intentions — two big questions hung over the announcement. First: Was it true? Second: As hopes for quick passage of the GOP health-care bill were fading, might it have been a cynical effort to distract from the chaos playing out on Capitol Hill?

What got skeptical spider-senses tingling on Twitter is how quickly officials from the Pentagon, State Department, and Central Command (the arm of the military that would carry out those strikes Spicer threatened) said they hadn’t been told of this warning in advance — and were not clear on what intelligence had provoked it. Commenters who either wanted to defend Trump or intimate they were privy to insider knowledge suggested that perhaps the warning was based on intelligence so secret that folks at the Pentagon and State didn’t know about it.

On the matter of factual veracity, let’s be clear about just how likely it is that Assad is in fact close to using chemical weapons. The U.N. has documented 160 cases of chemical-weapons use in Syria over the last six years, and considers another 131 incidents suspicious but unproven. The majority were committed by the Assad regime. Three hundred chemical attacks over six years — you do the math. The Trump administration could issue this warning once a week and be right more often than not. (Most chemical attacks since the 2014 effort to remove Assad’s weapons stocks seem to have weaponized commonly available chemicals such as chlorine. So as long as Bashar can keep his family’s swimming pools sparkling, he can also gas his opponents.)

Whatever intelligence the Trump administration had to show was enough to engender polite and cooperative responses from Britain and France. The French government said that Trump had spoken with President Macron — who just days earlier was trolling him to energize voters in parliamentary elections — about the need to forge a “common response” in the event of another attack. This is not diplomatic-speak for “we believe you,” but it’s not “get lost” either.

On Tuesday, no use of chemical weapons materialized — just another day of the regime attacking opposition forces in western Syria, close to the capital Damascus, the area Assad sees as his heartland. Meanwhile, U.S.-backed insurgents continued their slow advance on ISIS capital Raqqa, hundreds of miles away in the east. Just another day of regional geopolitics and nonchemical death for innocent civilians.

On Tuesday, the administration also offered its story of how the decision played out. Trump received the intelligence Monday morning. By the time the secretaries of State and Defense arrived at the White House for meetings with Indian Prime Minister Modi, Politico reported, they “were informed” of the plan to issue a statement, White House officials said, and had the opportunity to “work the language.” National Security Adviser H.R. McMaster “had already been briefed and weighed in on the plan.” Administration officials told the New York Times that cabinet members were “aware of” the plan to issue a statement.

But those passive constructions are not normal. A president’s national security adviser doesn’t get briefed on presidential statements on breaking security issues — he or she proposes them, chairs the meetings at which they are decided, and drafts them. Secretaries of Defense aren’t just “aware” of redline threats to use military force — they have explicitly signed off on them and have the Pentagon humming on plans to implement them. Secretaries of State are intimately engaged, not just “informed,” of plans to issue a military warning to a Russian client state.

It is not normal to move decision-making around highly sensitive intelligence from the president’s intelligence briefing directly to the press office, and only later back to the security professionals to work the text. Who were the objects of all those passive sentences, the senior officials doing the deciding and briefing and drafting? Was it just Spicey at his desk?

Plenty of critics on the left saw this as a Wag the Dog scenario of made-up intelligence. But the conflict in Syria is a dog that can wag its own tail, and ours too if we let it. And if the Trump White House is issuing ultimatums that its own national-security team doesn’t want to take full responsibility for, based on intelligence that is too secret to share with mid-level staff but not too secret to brief to Congress, chances are it’s not fully briefed on how that wagging tail will affect key players like Russia and Iran. That’s worse than cynical. It’s dumb. 


FOREIGN AFFAIRSShare on FacebookTweet this Story
Top Stories
Nothing About Trump’s Syria Announcement Was Normal
100 Years After the Bolshevik Revolution, Communism Hasn’t Changed
Trump Unaware of Trumpcare’s Single Most Important Feature

Most Viewed Stories

Pretty Little Liars’ Troian Bellisario on Her Big Finale Twist and Ungrateful Fans

The President of the United States Is Tweeting Vindictively About a TV Host’s Alleged Face-Lift

Snapchat’s New Map Feature Is the Best Social Media Time-Waster in Months
The Real Housewives of New York City Recap: Vermonsters
How ‘Wellness’ Became an Epidemic
Jared Kushner’s Road Map to Nowhere
Tumblr’s Unclear Future Shows That There’s No Money in Internet Culture
Watching and Lamenting the Death of the New York Diner
GOP Senators Begin to Question Health-Care Bill’s Tax Cuts for the Rich
The Best Actor on TV Is Better Call Saul’s Michael McKean

Trump Fired Comey Over the Clinton Email Probe He Once Praised Him For Handling


by Taboola
Promoted Links More to Explore

Hollywood Actress Tells All: “I Hope My Story Will Help Other Women”ActivatedYou

This Amazing Device Should Be BannedRadSpeed Detector Pro

Quicken Loans Urges Homeowners To Switch To A 15 Year FixedQuicken Loans, NMLS#3030


docb2 hours ago

Another take on the drumpf lies....

Nothing about the drumpf is NORMAL


Latest News from Daily Intelligencer11:32 a.m.Now That Phil Jackson Is Gone, What’s Next for the Knicks?

The end of the triangle could be the start of something for the Knicks.
11:14 a.m.Governor Andrew Cuomo Will Declare the MTA in a State of Emergency

He’s signing an executive order to speed up procurement and adding $1 billion to the capital plan.
11:09 a.m.Secretary of State Gives Up on Diplomacy, Berates White House

Tillerson is tired of the White House blocking his hires and letting the president’s son-in-law usurp his authority. And he’s done holding his tongue.
10:37 a.m.Trump Doesn’t Know What a Medicaid Cut Is

Like Newt Gingrich back in the 1990s, Trump is claiming increased Medicaid funding means the program is not being “cut.” That’s, at best, ignorance.
9:29 a.m.President of the U.S. Tweets Vindictively About TV Host’s Alleged Face-Lift

Good morning, everyone.
8:51 a.m.What Is Wrong With the MTA — and How Could It Get Fixed?

A transit expert provides some real talk.
8:00 a.m.Democrats Remain United Against GOP Health Plan Because It’s Politically Stupid

Unlike Republicans as recently as the Bush administration, today’s GOP is managing to alienate many of its own voters, and everyone else.
5:42 a.m.Son-in-Law, Yes, Grandparent, No. Who’s Allowed Under Trump’s New Visa Criteria

What counts as a “close familial relationship” for the purposes of the partial travel ban doesn’t make much sense.
2:02 a.m.Scenes From the Swamp: (Almost) Inside Trump’s $35,000-Per-Plate 2020 Fundraiser

The president started raising money for his 2020 campaign with an event held at his own D.C. hotel — and the press was forced to crash the party.
12:19 a.m.Perjury Charge Against Officer in Sandra Bland Case Dismissed

In a deal with prosecutors, Brian Encinia agreed never to work in law enforcement again.
Yesterday at 9:42 p.m.GOP Senators Begin to Question Health-Care Bill’s Tax Cuts for the Rich

The repeal of the taxes on the wealthy that were enacted with Obamacare is under attack by Senate Republicans. That is a bad sign for Mitch McConnell.
Yesterday at 6:34 p.m.A Limited Version of Trump’s Travel Ban Will Take Effect Thursday

Three days after the Supreme Court lifted the injunctions against the ban, the U.S. will begin barring visitors from six Muslim-majority nations.
Yesterday at 5:49 p.m.California’s Single-Payer Bill Halted by Democratic Assembly Speaker

Citing two big procedural bars to enactment of a single-payer plan, Speaker Anthony Rendon stopped action on it, inviting attacks from proponents.
Yesterday at 5:03 p.m.Trump Rethinks ‘Attack the Lead Investigator’ Approach to Russia Probe

Trump won’t file a complaint against James Comey for leaking (for now), as a gesture of goodwill toward Special Counsel Robert Mueller.
Yesterday at 4:34 p.m.Nothing About Trump’s Syria Announcement Was Normal

It came out of nowhere, and the backstory was even stranger — and more alarming.
Yesterday at 2:26 p.m.McConnell Has $188 Billion Fund to Save Health-Care Bill. How Will He Spend It?

Here’s how the enticements to wavering GOP senators might be doled out.
Yesterday at 2:05 p.m.Ted Cruz Has a Doppelgänger and It’s Really Freaky

The Texas senator has a doppelgänger.
Yesterday at 1:24 p.m.Trump Accuses Amazon of Tax Avoidance, Bankrolling ‘Fake News’

The president implicitly threatens Jeff Bezos with higher taxes, for owning a newspaper that reports critically on the White House.
Yesterday at 1:16 p.m.GOP Mayoral Hopeful Paul Massey Drops Out of Race

The real-estate developer cited the financial hurdles to taking out an incumbent.
Yesterday at 1:07 p.m.100 Years After the Bolshevik Revolution, Communism Hasn’t Changed

Marxists say they’ve learned their lesson and are ready for another chance.

No comments:

Post a Comment